Debunking as Positive Science

Authors

  • Richard York
  • Brett Clark

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.14452/MR-057-09-2006-02_2

Keywords:

Ecology

Abstract

The physicist Alan Sokal laid a trap for postmodernists and anti-science scholars on the academic left when he submitted his article, "Transgressing the Boundaries: Toward a Transformative Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity," to Social Text, a left-leaning cultural studies journal. The trap sprang when the journal unwittingly published the article in its 1996 spring/summer issue. The article was intended to parody the type of scholarship that has become common in some sectors of the academy, which substitutes word-play and sophistry for reason and evidence. Sokal purposefully included in his article a variety of false statements, illogical arguments, incomprehensible sentences, and absurd, unsupported assertions, including the claim that there was in effect no real world and all of science was merely a social construction. He submitted the article to test whether the editors of Social Text had any serious intellectual standards. They failed the test, and the scandal that ensued has become legend

Published

2006-02-02

Issue

Section

Review of the Month